Licenses for APs and Switches
-
@coliver said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@thwr said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@coliver said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
Make sure you include the labor in the comparison as well. Hanging new APs can get very costly.
I guess all the wires are already in place. Shouldn't be too hard to replace them
Still would be to get someone in a ladder or lift to do the replacement. I've done a 150 AP organization before that was a good week for two people.
The question is: Who should climb the ladder? Probably not someone who bills $150+ per hour.
-
@thwr said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@coliver said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@thwr said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@coliver said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
Make sure you include the labor in the comparison as well. Hanging new APs can get very costly.
I guess all the wires are already in place. Shouldn't be too hard to replace them
Still would be to get someone in a ladder or lift to do the replacement. I've done a 150 AP organization before that was a good week for two people.
The question is: Who should climb the ladder? Probably not someone who bills $150+ per hour.
That'll be me. They're cheap, but I know what I'm worth haha.
-
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@thwr said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@coliver said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@thwr said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@coliver said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
Make sure you include the labor in the comparison as well. Hanging new APs can get very costly.
I guess all the wires are already in place. Shouldn't be too hard to replace them
Still would be to get someone in a ladder or lift to do the replacement. I've done a 150 AP organization before that was a good week for two people.
The question is: Who should climb the ladder? Probably not someone who bills $150+ per hour.
That'll be me. They're cheap, but I know what I'm worth haha.
-
@thwr said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@thwr said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@coliver said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@thwr said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@coliver said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
Make sure you include the labor in the comparison as well. Hanging new APs can get very costly.
I guess all the wires are already in place. Shouldn't be too hard to replace them
Still would be to get someone in a ladder or lift to do the replacement. I've done a 150 AP organization before that was a good week for two people.
The question is: Who should climb the ladder? Probably not someone who bills $150+ per hour.
That'll be me. They're cheap, but I know what I'm worth haha.
One day I'll be worth that...one day...
-
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@thwr said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@thwr said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@coliver said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@thwr said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@coliver said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
Make sure you include the labor in the comparison as well. Hanging new APs can get very costly.
I guess all the wires are already in place. Shouldn't be too hard to replace them
Still would be to get someone in a ladder or lift to do the replacement. I've done a 150 AP organization before that was a good week for two people.
The question is: Who should climb the ladder? Probably not someone who bills $150+ per hour.
That'll be me. They're cheap, but I know what I'm worth haha.
One day I'll be worth that...one day...
A smiley? I guess you are already worth one
-
@jaredbusch said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
and keeping the MX400.
Why keep it? Clean house totally.
I wondered too. Dump that crap.
-
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@jaredbusch He likes the Layer 7 application blocking on the MX. I wanted to bring this up on a separate thread, but since you brought it up :D, I feel like that shouldn't really be an issue right?
Why does he like that? Make him put that feature into a dollar value.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@jaredbusch He likes the Layer 7 application blocking on the MX. I wanted to bring this up on a separate thread, but since you brought it up :D, I feel like that shouldn't really be an issue right?
Why does he like that? Make him put that feature into a dollar value.
I would love to. I'm going to include the price of keeping the MX in my proposal.
He says that he likes the ability of the layer 7 application blocking on the MX. But I feel like with appropriate firewall rules I could block those kinds of things, right? Even then the only thing I have under the Layer 7 rules blocks torrenting. -
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@jaredbusch He likes the Layer 7 application blocking on the MX. I wanted to bring this up on a separate thread, but since you brought it up :D, I feel like that shouldn't really be an issue right?
Why does he like that? Make him put that feature into a dollar value.
I would love to. I'm going to include the price of keeping the MX in my proposal.
He says that he likes the ability of the layer 7 application blocking on the MX. But I feel like with appropriate firewall rules I could block those kinds of things, right? Even then the only thing I have under the Layer 7 rules blocks torrenting.Depends, what exactly is he blocking? And why?
-
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@jaredbusch He likes the Layer 7 application blocking on the MX. I wanted to bring this up on a separate thread, but since you brought it up :D, I feel like that shouldn't really be an issue right?
Why does he like that? Make him put that feature into a dollar value.
I would love to. I'm going to include the price of keeping the MX in my proposal.
He says that he likes the ability of the layer 7 application blocking on the MX. But I feel like with appropriate firewall rules I could block those kinds of things, right? Even then the only thing I have under the Layer 7 rules blocks torrenting.Depends, what exactly is he blocking? And why?
We're looking to block things like P2P, adult content, basically anything a school should block.
Realistically, wouldn't a Pfsense router with a plugin like Pfblocker, or squidguard block stuff like that? I have a pfsense box at home, but I haven't been messing with plugins like I should. -
With that campus the size that it is, I would definitely recommend finding something to handle the Layer7 stuff.
I'm relatively certain you could drop in Ubiquiti APs, and possibly grab a Palo Alto that could work and still come out cheaper than doing the licenses for the Meraki gear.
-
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@markferron said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@jaredbusch He likes the Layer 7 application blocking on the MX. I wanted to bring this up on a separate thread, but since you brought it up :D, I feel like that shouldn't really be an issue right?
Why does he like that? Make him put that feature into a dollar value.
I would love to. I'm going to include the price of keeping the MX in my proposal.
He says that he likes the ability of the layer 7 application blocking on the MX. But I feel like with appropriate firewall rules I could block those kinds of things, right? Even then the only thing I have under the Layer 7 rules blocks torrenting.Depends, what exactly is he blocking? And why?
We're looking to block things like P2P, adult content, basically anything a school should block.
Realistically, wouldn't a Pfsense router with a plugin like Pfblocker, or squidguard block stuff like that? I have a pfsense box at home, but I haven't been messing with plugins like I should.Those are two different kinds of things. One is blocking an app. The other is blocking sites. I’d handle those separately.
-
Consider something like Strongarm.io for blocking content.
-
Ubiquiti firewalls do P2P blocking, just turn it on.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
Ubiquiti firewalls do P2P blocking, just turn it on.
Not so much
-
@jaredbusch said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
Ubiquiti firewalls do P2P blocking, just turn it on.
Not so much
It blocks some at least.
-
Is it a business requirement? Seems like that would need to be something that should be determined prior to paying for it again.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@jaredbusch said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
Ubiquiti firewalls do P2P blocking, just turn it on.
Not so much
It blocks some at least.
Are you talking about these settings? I’ve not had much luck with it. But it has been a couple years since I tried. I will test it again.
-
@coliver said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
Is it a business requirement? Seems like that would need to be something that should be determined prior to paying for it again.
It's for a school. But definitely someone should determine if it is "this one guy wants this for his own personal reasons" or "this is actually something that the school should have."
-
@jaredbusch said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@jaredbusch said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
@scottalanmiller said in Licenses for APs and Switches:
Ubiquiti firewalls do P2P blocking, just turn it on.
Not so much
It blocks some at least.
Are you talking about these settings? I’ve not had much luck with it. But it has been a couple years since I tried. I will test it again.
That's the settings, yeah. Don't know how good it is, but it's something (and free.)
